Skip to content

Real photos of every game  ·  Ships in 1–2 business days  ·  Questions? We’re here to help

🎁 Holiday order-by dates: USPS Ground by Tue Dec 15 · Priority Mail by Wed Dec 16  ·  All dates & carriers

Coolection
Close
Shop Video Games Shop Trading Cards Sign In 0 Wishlist Cart
00 items
Menu Close
  • Nintendo
    Nintendo
    Go to Nintendo
    Console Games
    Console Games
    • Go to Console Games
    • Nintendo Entertainment System
      • Shop All NES Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • Super Nintendo Entertainment System
      • Shop All SNES Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • N64 Console System
      • Shop all N64 Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • GameCube Console System
      • Shop All GameCube Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • Wii Console System
      • Shop All Wii Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
      • Sealed
    • Wii U Console System
      • Shop All Wii U Games
      • Complete in Box
      • Sealed
    • Switch Console System
      • Shop All Switch Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
      • Sealed
    • Switch 2 Console System
      • Shop All Switch 2 Games
      • Sealed
    Handheld Games
    Handheld Games
    • Go to Handheld Games
    • GameBoy
      • Shop All Game Boy Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • GameBoy Color
      • Shop All Game Boy Color Games
      • Game Only
    • GameBoy Advance
      • Shop All Game Boy Advance Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • DS
      • Shop All DS Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • 3DS
      • Shop All 3DS Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    Shop Nintendo by
    • Loose
    • Complete in box
    • Sealed
    • Under $20
    • Grails · $500 and up
    Top shelf this week See this one →
    Coolection
  • Sony PlayStation
    Sony PlayStation
    Go to Sony PlayStation
    Console Games
    Console Games
    • Go to Console Games
    • PlayStation 1
      • Shop All PlayStation 1 Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
      • Sealed
    • PlayStation 2
      • Shop All PlayStation 2 Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
      • Sealed
    • PlayStation 3
      • Shop All PlayStation 3 Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
      • Sealed
    • PlayStation 4
      • Shop All PlayStation 4 Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
      • Sealed
    • PlayStation 5
      • Shop All PlayStation 5 Games
      • Complete in Box
      • Sealed
    Handheld Games
    Handheld Games
    • Go to Handheld Games
    • PS Vita
      • Shop All PS Vita Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • PSP
      • Shop All PSP Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    Shop PlayStation by
    • Loose
    • Complete in box
    • Sealed
    • Under $20
    • Grails · $150 and up
    Top shelf this week See this one →
    Coolection
  • Xbox
    Xbox
    Go to Xbox
    Xbox Classic
    Xbox Classic
    • Go to Xbox Classic
    • Shop All Xbox Classic Games
    • Game Only
    • Complete in Box
    Xbox 360
    Xbox 360
    • Go to Xbox 360
    • Shop All Xbox 360 Games
    • Game Only
    • Complete in Box
    • Sealed
    Xbox One Console
    Xbox One Console
    • Go to Xbox One Console
    • Shop All Xbox One Games
    • Game Only
    • Complete in Box
    • Sealed
    Xbox Series X Console
    Xbox Series X Console
    • Go to Xbox Series X Console
    • Shop All Xbox Series X Games
    • Complete in Box
    • Sealed
    Top shelf this week See this one →
    Loose Complete in box SealedUnder $20 Grails $40+
    Coolection
  • Vintage & Classic Systems
    Vintage & Classic Systems
    Go to Vintage & Classic Systems
    Atari
    Atari
    • Go to Atari
    • ATARI 2600
      • Shop All Atari 2600 Games
      • Game Only
    • ATARI 5200
      • Shop All Atari 5200 Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • ATARI 7800
      • Shop All Atari 7800 Games
      • Game Only
    Sega
    Sega
    • Go to Sega
    • Sega Master
      • Shop All Sega Master System Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • Sega Genesis
      • Shop All Sega Genesis Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • Sega CD Console System
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
      • Shop All Sega CD Games
    • Sega Game Gear
      • Shop All Sega Game Gear Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • Sega Saturn
      • Shop All Sega Saturn Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    • Sega DreamCast
      • Shop All Sega Dreamcast Games
      • Game Only
      • Complete in Box
    Turbografx-16
    Turbografx-16
    • Go to Turbografx-16
    • Shop All TurboGrafx-16 Games
    • Game Only
    • Complete in Box
    Intellivision
    Intellivision
    • Go to Intellivision
    • Shop All Intellivision Games
    • Complete in Box
    Top shelf this week See this one →
    Loose Complete in box SealedUnder $20 Grails $500+
    Coolection
  • Consoles & Hardware
    Consoles & Hardware
    Go to Consoles & Hardware
    Consoles
    Consoles
    • Go to Consoles
    • Nintendo
    • PlayStation
    • Sega
    • Micro & modern retro
    Accessories
    Accessories
    • Go to Accessories
    • Nintendo
    • PlayStation
    • Xbox
    • Sega
    • Analogue
    Collectibles
    Collectibles
    • Go to Collectibles
    • Strategy guides
    • Mini replica game boxes
    • Retro merch
    Top shelf this week See this one →
    Loose Complete in box SealedUnder $20 Grails $500+
    Coolection
  • Magic: The Gathering
    Magic: The Gathering
    Go to Magic: The Gathering
    Single Cards
    Single Cards
    • Go to Single Cards
    • Block sets & Expansions
      • View All
    • Reprint & Masters Sets
      • View All
    • Masterpiece Sets & Insert Cards
      • Amonkhet Invocations
      • Double Masters Borderless
      • Double Masters 2022 Borderless
      • Kaladesh Inventions
      • Mythic Editions
      • Ultimate Masters Box Toppers
      • View All
    • Commander & Multiplayer Sets
      • View All
    • Judge & Media Promos
      • View All
    • Secret Lair Series
      • Secret Lair Singles
      • Secret Lair: Ultimate Edition
      • Secret Lair 30th: Anniversary Countdown Kit
      • View All
    Sealed Product
    Sealed Product
    • Go to Sealed Product
    • View Sealed Products
    Supplies
    Supplies
    • Go to Supplies
    • View Supplies
    Top shelf this week See this one →
    Singles SealedUnder $20 Grails $500+
    Coolection
  • Pokemon
    Pokemon
    Go to Pokemon
    Single Cards
    Single Cards
    • Go to Single Cards
    • Vintage (WotC era)
    • Base Set
    • Jungle · Fossil · Team Rocket
    • Mega Evolution
    • Scarlet & Violet
    • Sword & Shield
    • World Championship Decks
    Sealed Product
    Sealed Product
    • Go to Sealed Product
    • View Sealed Products
    Supplies
    Supplies
    • Go to Supplies
    • View Supplies
    Top shelf this week See this one →
    Singles SealedUnder $20 Grails $500+
    Coolection
  • Lorcana
    Lorcana
    Go to Lorcana
    Single Cards
    Single Cards
    • Go to Single Cards
    • The First Chapter
      • View All
    • Rise of the Floodborn
      • View All
    • Into the Inklands
      • View All
    • Shimmering Skies
      • View All
    Sealed Product
    Sealed Product
    • Go to Sealed Product
    • View Sealed Products
    Supplies
    Supplies
    • Go to Supplies
    • View Supplies
    Top shelf this week See this one →
    Singles SealedUnder $20 Grails $15+
    Coolection
  • Supplies
  • Watch & Read
Cart
00 items
Coolection
Log in
Cart
00 items
Home Magic: The Gathering
Close
Filters

Filters

Reset filters

Category

  • Single Cards
    • Block sets & Expansions
      • View All
    • Reprint & Masters Sets
      • View All
    • Masterpiece Sets & Insert Cards
      • Amonkhet Invocations
      • Double Masters Borderless
      • Double Masters 2022 Borderless
      • Kaladesh Inventions
      • Mythic Editions
      • Ultimate Masters Box Toppers
      • View All
    • Commander & Multiplayer Sets
      • View All
    • Judge & Media Promos
      • View All
    • Secret Lair Series
      • Secret Lair Singles
      • Secret Lair: Ultimate Edition
      • Secret Lair 30th: Anniversary Countdown Kit
      • View All
  • Sealed Product
    • View Sealed Products
  • Supplies
    • View Supplies
Showing 4730 results for "Magic: The Gathering"

    Magic: The Gathering

    4730 listings

    Filters
    4730 listings
    50
    • 10
    • 15
    • 20
    • 25
    • 30
    • 50
    Title: A–Z
    • Featured
    • Most relevant
    • Best selling
    • Title: A–Z
    • Title: Z–A
    • Price: low to high
    • Price: high to low
    • Oldest listings
    • Newest arrivals
    Sort

    Sort by:

    • Featured
    • Most relevant
    • Best selling
    • Title: A–Z
    • Title: Z–A
    • Price: low to high
    • Price: high to low
    • Oldest listings
    • Newest arrivals
    • Ice-Fang Coatl Ice-Fang CoatlModern Horizons 1 TimeshiftsNear MintFoil$4.99
    • Sold outIcetill Explorer (Extended Art) Icetill ExplorerEdge of EternitiesExtended Art$23.99
    • Idyllic Tutor Idyllic TutorTheros Beyond DeathNear MintNon-foilFrom $14.99
    • Idyllic Tutor Idyllic TutorSecret Lair SinglesNear MintFoil$21.99
    • Ignoble Hierarch Ignoble HierarchModern Horizons 2Near MintFoilFrom $1.99
    • Ignoble Hierarch Ignoble HierarchSecret Lair SinglesNear MintFoil$39.99
    • Ikra Shidiqi, the Usurper Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperCommander LegendsNear MintFoil$5.99
    • Ikra Shidiqi, the Usurper Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperCommander 2016Near MintFoil$1.99
    • Ilharg, the Raze-Boar Ilharg, the Raze-BoarSecret Lair SinglesNear MintFoil$20.99
    • Ilharg, the Raze-Boar Ilharg, the Raze-BoarWar of the SparkNear MintNon-foil$8.99
    • Illuna, Apex of Wishes Illuna, Apex of WishesPrerelease CardsNear MintFoil$3.99
    • Impact Tremors Impact TremorsSecret Lair SinglesNear MintFoil$13.99
    • Impact Tremors - Secret Lair Drop #1999 - Borderless Foil Impact TremorsSecret Lair DropNear MintDrop #1999 · Borderless Foil$7.99
    • Imperial Recruiter Imperial RecruiterModern Horizons 2Near MintNon-foilFrom $14.99
    • Imperial Recruiter Imperial RecruiterMasters 25Near MintNon-foil$17.99
    • Sold outImperial Recruiter Imperial RecruiterDouble Masters$14.99
    • Sold outImperial Seal Imperial SealJudge Promos$360.99
    • Imperial Seal Imperial SealDouble Masters 2022Near MintFoil$250.99
    • Imperial Seal Imperial SealMasterpiece Series: Double Masters 2022 BorderlessNear MintFoil$224.99
    • Impervious Greatwurm Impervious GreatwurmDouble Masters 2022Near MintFoil$12.99
    • Sold outImpervious Greatwurm Impervious GreatwurmBuy-a-Box Promos$5.99
    • Imposter Mech Imposter MechBlock Set Commander SinglesNear MintNon-foil$9.99
    • Imprisoned in the Moon Imprisoned in the MoonSecret Lair SinglesNear MintFoil$16.99
    • Imprisoned in the Moon - Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal #14 - Borderless Non-Foil Imprisoned in the MoonAvatar: The Last Airbender Eternal #14Near MintBorderless Non-Foil$3.99
    • Impulse ImpulseFrom the Vault SinglesNear MintFoil$1.99
    • In the Trenches (Rainbow Foil) In the TrenchesSecret Lair SinglesNear MintRainbow Foil$1.99
    • Sold outInalla, Archmage Ritualist Inalla, Archmage RitualistSecret Lair Singles$10.99
    • Inalla, Archmage Ritualist - Final Fantasy: Through the Ages #52 - Borderless Non-Foil Inalla, Archmage RitualistFinal Fantasy: Through the Ages #52Near MintBorderless Non-Foil$1.99
    • Increasing Vengeance Increasing VengeanceStrixhaven Mystical ArchiveNear MintFoil$11.99
    • Increasing Vengeance (JP Alternate Art) (Foil - Etched) Increasing Vengeance (JP Alternate Art)Strixhaven Mystical ArchiveNear MintFoil - Etched$11.99
    • Sold outIndominus Rex - Polyraptor Indominus Rex - PolyraptorSecret Lair Singles$39.99
    • Indomitable Creativity Indomitable CreativityAether RevoltNear MintNon-foil$0.99
    • Inexorable Tide Inexorable TideModern Masters 2015 EditionNear MintNon-foil$8.99
    • Infernal Grasp Infernal GraspPromo Pack: Innistrad: Midnight HuntNear MintNon-foil$1.99
    • Infernal Tutor Infernal TutorDissensionNear MintNon-foil$1.99
    • Inferno of the Star Mounts Inferno of the Star MountsAdventures in the Forgotten RealmsNear MintNon-foilFrom $3.99
    • Inferno Titan Inferno TitanSecret Lair SinglesNear MintNon-foil$4.99
    • Infuriate InfuriateStrixhaven Mystical ArchiveNear MintNon-foil$0.99
    • Ingenious Mastery Ingenious MasteryStrixhaven: School of MagesNear MintNon-foil$0.99
    • Sold outInigo, Avenging Swordsman - Samut, Voice of Dissent Inigo, Avenging Swordsman - Samut, Voice of DissentSecret Lair Singles$41.99
    • Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni Ink-Eyes, Servant of OniFrom the Vault SinglesNear MintFoil$19.99
    • Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni Ink-Eyes, Servant of OniMTG Board GamesNear MintNon-foil$14.99
    • Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni Ink-Eyes, Servant of OniSecret Lair SinglesNear MintFoil$16.99
    • Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni - Secret Lair Drop #2374 - Borderless Foil Ink-Eyes, Servant of OniSecret Lair DropNear MintDrop #2374 · Borderless Foil$10.99
    • Inkmoth Nexus Inkmoth NexusMirrodin BesiegedNear MintNon-foil$16.99
    • Sold outInkmoth Nexus Inkmoth NexusSecret Lair Singles$11.99
    • Sold outInkmoth Nexus Inkmoth NexusSecret Lair Singles$18.99
    • Inkshield InkshieldCommander 2021Near MintNon-foil$6.99
    • Inquisition of Kozilek Inquisition of KozilekStrixhaven Mystical ArchiveNear MintFoilFrom $0.99
    • Inquisition of Kozilek Inquisition of KozilekSecret Lair SinglesNear MintFoil$10.99

    Showing 1901–1950 of 4730 listings · Page 39 of 95

    • Previous
    • 1
    • …
    • 37
    • 38
    • 39
    • 40
    • 41
    • …
    • 95
    • Next

    Ships in 1–2 business days

    Orders go out Monday–Friday with tracking. Signature required on orders $250+.

    Real photos of our items

    The item in the pictures is the one you get. Every listing says if a stock image is shown instead.

    Help with your order

    Something wrong with your order? Contact us within 14 days of delivery and we’ll make it right. See how it works.

    Discover new arrivals

    Get new arrivals, collecting stories, and convention dates in your inbox. Keep me posted.

    Coolection

    Retro video games, consoles, and trading cards—carefully described, securely packed, and shipped from Bucks County, PA.

    • Our eBay store Opens in a new window.
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • TikTok
    • YouTube

    SHOP

    • Shop Video Games
    • Shop Trading Cards
    • New Arrivals
    • Supplies
    • Our eBay Auctions
    • Wishlist

    COMPANY

    • About Us
    • Blog
    • Watch
    • Conventions
    • Contact Us
    • Terms of Service

    HELP

    • Help & FAQ
    • Shipping Policy
    • Refund Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Your Privacy Choices
    • Make an offer on a list

    CONTACT

    Coolection, LLC support@coolection.com 267-347-9567
    Doylestown, PA 18902
    Mon–Fri 10AM–10PM ET Where we’ll be: Too Many Games · Jun 25–27, 2027 · Oaks, PA All dates →

    FIND OUT WHAT'S NEXT

    Get new arrivals, collecting stories, and upcoming convention dates in your inbox.

    You have been subscribed successfully!
    This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
    © 2026 Coolection, LLC. All rights reserved.
    TermsPrivacyYour Privacy Choices
    • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.

    Thanks for subscribing!

    This email has been registered!

    Shop the look

    Close

    Choose Options

    Close
    Close
    Edit Option
    this is just a warning
    Login Close
    Forgot your password? Create account
    Close
    Your cart
    0 items
    ✓ Added to cart
    Close
    Search games, consoles, cards…
    Close
    Menu Close
    Shop all games Shop all cards
    • New this week
    • Our eBay auctions
    • Help & FAQ
    • Sell or trade
    Sign In Create an Account
    My Wish List